The Cost of an Untested Business Idea
Why a promising idea needs evidence, not just enthusiasm.
By Elijah E
Why a promising idea needs evidence, not just enthusiasm.
By Elijah E
By Elijah E. Uyok
Founder of Zanniversal Ltd.
Published under Zanniversal Insights
🗓️8 October 2026
One of the most expensive mistakes in business is not necessarily making a bad decision. Sometimes, it is making a decision before gathering enough information to know whether it is a good one.
A business idea can sound convincing. Someone may tell you that a particular product sells well. You may observe people showing interest in it. You may even imagine how much money it could bring in. But there is a difference between believing a business opportunity exists and gathering enough evidence to establish that it does. I began to understand this distinction through an experience with my father's younger sister, Aunt Agbansu.
Her story was different from Aunt Comfort's, whose business I discussed in the previous article. Aunt Comfort had a vision of growing her provision business into a larger operation, but she lacked a clear process for getting there. Aunt Agbansu's situation was different. She was primarily trying to survive, and her business did not have a clearly defined growth direction.
That difference matters because a business does not operate independently of the circumstances and decisions that shape it. The owner's purpose, available resources, understanding of customers, and approach to decision-making can influence what the business becomes.
But the lesson I learned from Aunt Agbansu went beyond the absence of a long-term vision. It concerned what happens when a business decision is made on the strength of a suggestion rather than evidence.
After completing my last term of Junior Secondary School 3 while living with Aunt Comfort, I moved to stay with my father's younger sister, Agbansu, in Awi, Cross River State.
At first, the experience seemed promising. The school was good, and I was settling into a different environment. But after about two weeks, the holiday period ended, and I gradually became involved in another household's business.
Aunt Agbansu was a single mother of two who sold herbal drinks and cigarettes to earn a living. Her business operated from a small, casual spot where a few men came to relax, drink, smoke, talk, and eventually leave. It was a different business environment from the provision shop I had known while living with Aunt Comfort.
I helped at the spot after school. Sometimes, smoke from the customers' cigarettes would blow in my direction, making the environment uncomfortable for me.
Then came the kerosene idea.
According to my experience, a friend of Aunt Agbansu suggested that she could make good money by selling kerosene. She acted on that suggestion and bought 25 litres. She divided the kerosene into smaller containers and displayed them outside her existing business.
On the first day, some passersby asked about the kerosene. That initial attention made the additional business look promising. It appeared that adding another product to the existing operation might be a good move. But asking about a product is not the same as buying it consistently. The expected demand did not materialise. Rather than attracting the customers she had anticipated, the kerosene became something Aunt Agbansu herself was using. Eventually, she asked me to hawk it. And that was how another business idea became another selling responsibility for me.
My experience did not end with kerosene. I was also sent out to sell other products, including oil and mangoes. One incident remains particularly vivid in my memory. I remember being woken around 2 a.m. and sent out to sell pork at a vigil held before a burial the following day. I returned around 6 a.m. having sold only two pieces. Some people apparently thought the pork was meat being distributed by the organisers of the event. I also had an examination that morning.
I share this detail not to turn the story into a complaint or to suggest that every difficult selling experience is the result of poor planning. Selling is uncertain, and not every product will perform as expected.
The point is that a decision made without adequate consideration can create consequences beyond the money spent on stock. It can also create additional work, consume time, and place responsibilities on other people. In my case, the kerosene did not simply represent a product that failed to sell as expected. It represented an opportunity that had been pursued without enough evidence, with the consequences eventually extending to me.
Looking back, I see a business lesson that I could not fully articulate at the time: a business idea should be examined before resources and effort are committed to it.
It would be easy to conclude that selling kerosene was simply a bad idea. That would be an incomplete lesson. Kerosene can be a useful product. In a location where people need it, can afford it, and have convenient access to it, selling kerosene may be a viable business. The problem was not necessarily the product itself. The problem was the decision-making process that led to the purchase.
From my account of the experience, there was no meaningful market survey, no clear identification of the intended customers, and no feasibility assessment before the 25 litres were purchased.
A suggestion was made, and the business acted on it. That is the difference between an idea and a business opportunity.
An idea describes something you could do. A business opportunity requires a reasonable basis for believing that people will buy what you offer at a price that can sustain the operation.
The distinction is important because entrepreneurs often confuse three things:
Possibility: People could buy this product.
Interest: Some people have shown curiosity about it.
Evidence of demand: Enough of the right customers are willing and able to buy it, at a price and frequency that make the business commercially sensible.
These are not interchangeable. A passerby asking the price of kerosene may be interested. But the question does not establish that the person will buy it, return to buy more, or generate enough revenue for the seller to cover the relevant costs. Likewise, seeing another person sell a product successfully does not automatically mean that the same product will succeed in your location. The other seller may have a different customer base, a better location, lower purchasing costs, stronger relationships with suppliers, or a more convenient way of serving customers.
A product can be good while the business opportunity, as currently designed, is weak. That is why the first question should not be, "Can I sell this?" It should be, "What evidence suggests that I can sell enough of this, to the right customers, under conditions that make the business worthwhile?"
Before committing money to a new product or business idea, there are five questions worth answering.
A business cannot make good decisions about demand without understanding whom it intends to serve. Aunt Agbansu already had customers who visited her spot to drink, smoke, and socialise. However, the presence of those customers did not automatically establish that they were also kerosene buyers. Some might have needed kerosene. Others might have had no use for it at all. Even customers who needed it might have preferred to buy it elsewhere. A business owner must therefore distinguish between existing customers and customers who are likely to buy the new product.
Consider a shop that sells snacks and soft drinks and wants to introduce cooking gas refills. The shop's existing customers may provide useful information, but their presence alone does not prove demand for gas refills. The owner would need to understand local household needs, safety and storage requirements, regulations, supply arrangements, and whether the location is suitable for such an operation.
The lesson is not that businesses should never diversify. It is that a new product should have a credible customer base.
Ask yourself:
Who needs this product?
How often do they need it?
What do they currently use or buy instead?
Where do they currently buy it?
What would make them buy from me?
If you cannot answer these questions, you may still have an idea worth exploring. You simply do not have enough information to justify a major commitment.
Demand is not just about whether people need a product in general. It is also about whether enough potential customers in a particular location are likely to buy it from you.
A product that sells quickly in one neighbourhood may move slowly in another. A busy road may generate attention without generating purchases. A shop may receive many visitors who are not part of the product's target market. This is why location must be assessed in relation to the product and the customer. For a small business, initial research does not have to be expensive. It may involve observing potential customers, speaking with people who might buy the product, checking what nearby sellers offer, and asking how frequently the product is purchased.
However, research should go beyond asking people whether they like an idea. People may express approval because they want to be encouraging, because they are curious, or because they have not considered what it would cost them to buy.
Where practical, evidence becomes stronger when people take a concrete step: placing an order, making a purchase, agreeing to a properly defined trial, or demonstrating a repeated buying pattern.
The goal is not to eliminate uncertainty. That is rarely possible. The goal is to reduce avoidable uncertainty before committing resources.
Even when demand exists, the business must consider how customers are already meeting that need. If several sellers already offer the same product nearby, customers may have little reason to switch unless the new seller provides some advantage. That advantage does not always have to be a lower price. It could be convenience, reliable availability, better service, consistent quality, appropriate packaging, or easier access.
For Aunt Agbansu's kerosene venture, the important questions would have included whether people nearby needed kerosene, where they currently purchased it, whether existing sellers served them adequately, and what would make them buy from her instead.
We cannot conclude from my account exactly which of these factors caused the venture to underperform. The story does not establish that. But these are the kinds of questions that should have been investigated before the purchase.
Competition is not automatically a reason to avoid a business. It is a reason to understand the market in which the business will operate.
A product can sell and still fail to produce a worthwhile return. The owner needs to understand the purchase price, expected selling price, transport, packaging, handling, losses, and other costs that apply to the operation. Let's use a hypothetical example. These figures are illustrative and are not figures from Aunt Agbansu's business.
Suppose an entrepreneur buys a batch of goods for ₦20,000 and sells the entire batch for ₦25,000.
Sales revenue
Cost of goods
Gross profit
Transport and other direct expenses
Amount remaining before other overheads and applicable taxes
₦25,000
₦20,000
₦5,000
₦3,000
₦2,000
The entrepreneur has made ₦25,000 in sales, but the amount remaining after the costs shown is only ₦2,000.
And that is not necessarily the final net profit. There may be other expenses that have not yet been included. This example illustrates why a business owner must look beyond the money received from customers. The selling price must cover the product's cost and the costs of making the sale, with enough left over to support the business.
The owner should also consider how quickly the stock is likely to sell. Money tied up in slow-moving stock cannot easily be used to replenish faster-selling products or meet other business needs. A product may offer an attractive margin on paper but still be unsuitable if it takes too long to sell, requires excessive effort, or exposes the business to unacceptable risk.
A business owner does not always need to make a large purchase to learn whether a product has potential. Where the product, regulations, safety requirements, and supply arrangements permit it, the owner can begin with a small trial, a limited quantity, or another low-cost test. The idea is to gather useful information before making a larger commitment. For example, an entrepreneur considering a new packaged food product might first test a small batch with a defined group of potential customers. The entrepreneur could track how many people actually buy, which price they accept, what feedback they give, and whether they buy again.
The entrepreneur should decide in advance what would count as a promising result. Otherwise, it becomes easy to interpret every outcome as a reason to continue.
A useful test should answer a business question. It should not merely create the feeling that progress is being made.
Market validation does not have to begin with an expensive consultant's report or a large research budget. The method should be proportionate to the size and risk of the decision.
For a small venture, the process can be simple.
Step 1: State the assumption.
Write down exactly what you believe to be true.
For example: "Households in this area will buy kerosene from my location because it is convenient."
That is an assumption, not yet a proven fact.
Step 2: Identify what would prove or weaken the assumption.
Would people buy at your proposed price? Are there enough potential customers nearby? Are existing sellers already meeting the need? Can you source the product reliably?
The answers should help you decide what information to collect.
Step 3: Gather evidence from potential customers and the market.
Speak to likely customers, observe buying patterns, compare competitors, and investigate the practical requirements of supplying the product. Where appropriate, seek actual purchases or commitments rather than relying only on verbal interest.
Step 4: Calculate the economics.
Estimate the full cost of the test, the expected selling price, the quantity that must be sold, and the amount that could remain after expenses. Be honest about the uncertainty in those estimates.
Step 5: Run a controlled test and record the results.
Track the quantity purchased, quantity sold, money received, expenses, remaining stock, customer feedback, and time spent. Without records, it is difficult to know whether the test has produced useful evidence.
Step 6: Make a decision based on the results.
Continue, adjust, test again, or stop. The outcome should depend on what the evidence supports, not on the desire to prove that the original idea was right.
A test that reveals weak demand has not necessarily wasted money. If it was small and affordable, it may have prevented a much larger loss.
When people evaluate a business idea, they often focus on the money invested. But the financial investment is only one part of the cost. There is also time, energy, attention, and the opportunity to do something else.
My experience with hawking made this lesson personal. The kerosene venture did not perform as expected, and the responsibility of trying to sell it fell to me. Other selling assignments also consumed time and energy, including the night I returned from selling pork shortly before an examination. I do not use these experiences to suggest that every unsuccessful product creates the same consequences. Rather, they remind me that business decisions can affect people beyond the person who makes the investment.
In a family business, the person doing the selling may not be the person who selected the product. In a small company, employees may be expected to execute a decision they did not help evaluate. In a partnership, one person's enthusiasm may commit the time or money of several people.
That makes the quality of decision-making even more important.
Before launching a product, ask not only whether the business can afford the financial risk, but also what the test will demand from the people involved. Is the workload reasonable? Is the selling process safe? Is the time commitment justified by the likely return? Are responsibilities clear?
These questions do not make an entrepreneur timid. They help the entrepreneur take risks deliberately rather than accidentally.
Another mistake can happen after a business idea begins to underperform.
Because money has already been spent, the owner may feel compelled to keep going. More money is invested, more time is committed, and more effort is demanded in the hope of recovering the original investment.
This is sometimes called the sunk-cost trap: allowing resources already spent to dictate a decision that should be based on what makes sense from this point forward.
Imagine that an entrepreneur purchases a product and discovers that customers are not buying it at the expected rate. The entrepreneur might respond by buying more stock, spending more on promotion, or expanding the selling effort without first understanding why demand is weak.
That response can deepen the problem.
A better approach is to pause and investigate. Is the price wrong? Is the product unsuitable for the target customer? Is the location poor? Is awareness too low? Is there a practical barrier to purchase? Or is the original assumption about demand simply unsupported? Each possibility requires a different response.
If a small change could solve the problem, a carefully measured adjustment may be sensible. If the product is poorly matched to the market, changing the offer or target customer may be necessary. If the evidence continues to show that the idea is not commercially viable, stopping may be the most responsible decision. The fact that money has already been spent does not mean more money should follow it.
A business owner must be willing to learn from a failed test, not merely defend the decision that created it.
If you are considering a new product, service, or business venture, take a few minutes to answer these questions before committing significant resources.
[ ] What customer problem am I trying to solve?
[ ] Who is most likely to pay for the solution?
[ ] What evidence shows that these customers want it?
[ ] How do they currently solve the problem?
[ ] What makes my offer competitive or convenient?
[ ] What will it cost to deliver the product or service?
[ ] What selling price is realistic?
[ ] How much must I sell to cover the relevant costs?
[ ] What is the smallest safe and practical test I can run?
[ ] What result would convince me to continue, adjust, or stop?
[ ] Who else will bear the workload or consequences if the idea performs poorly?
You do not need perfect answers to every question before taking any action. Some information only becomes available through testing. But you should know which assumptions you are making, which risks you are accepting, and what you need to learn before investing more. The purpose of planning is not to guarantee success. It is to make decisions more informed, risks more visible, and mistakes less expensive.
Aunt Agbansu's story remains an important part of how I think about business. She was trying to make a living, and I recognise that the pressures of survival can make quick decisions attractive. When resources are limited, an idea that promises additional income can feel like an opportunity that should not be missed.
But urgency does not remove the need for judgment.
A business does not become viable simply because someone recommends it. A product does not become profitable simply because people ask about it. And a new activity does not automatically improve a business just because it creates another potential source of revenue. An idea deserves investigation before it receives a substantial commitment of money, time, and effort.
My experience also taught me to look beyond the product itself. The foundation of a business includes the reason it exists, the customers it serves, the decisions its owner makes, and the process through which those decisions are tested and improved.
Aunt Comfort had a vision but lacked a reliable process for pursuing it. Aunt Agbansu's business, as I experienced it, was driven more by immediate survival than by a defined growth direction. Their situations were different, but both experiences pushed me toward the same question: what must happen between having an idea and building a business that can sustain itself?
That question becomes even more important when the product is exposed to changing prices, uncertain supply, transport costs, and shifting market conditions.
In the next article, I will discuss my mother's agricultural trading business, where the same product could produce a profit on one market day and a loss on another. That experience introduces another essential business lesson: making a sale is not the same as making a profit, and a profitable transaction today does not guarantee a profitable one tomorrow.
🗓️5 October 2026
Zanniversal Ltd. is a digital solutions and business systems company helping entrepreneurs, startups, growing businesses, and organisations strengthen their foundations, improve their operations, and make better use of technology. Its services include business setup support, branding, websites and digital presence, digital marketing, workflow automation, corporate documentation, customer-support systems, consulting, and custom digital solutions.
Through practical, technology-enabled solutions, Zanniversal aims to help businesses work more effectively, reduce avoidable inefficiencies, strengthen customer experiences, and build towards sustainable growth.
Zanniversal — Digital Solutions & Business Systems.
Elijah E. Uyok is the founder of Zanniversal Ltd., a digital solutions and business systems company. His interest in business began through firsthand exposure to trading and family enterprises, and developed through his own entrepreneurial experiences, his study of Computer Software Engineering, and his work across technology, digital services, and creative fields.
Through Business, Beyond Survival, published under Zanniversal Insights, he shares lessons from businesses he witnessed, participated in, and built. The series explores the decisions, habits, systems, and personal development that can help entrepreneurs better understand their businesses and work towards building them more sustainably.